Thursday, January 17, 2013

Briefs Filed by Petitioner and His Amici in Bowman v. Monsanto


In Bowman v. Monsanto, the Supreme Court will have the opportunity to address the extent to which the doctrine of patent exhaustion applies to progeny of patented recombinant seeds. For background on the case, see this previous post.
Here are links to briefs recently filed by petitioner Bowman and his amici, with some brief commentary:

Petitioner (Vernon Bowman) argues that an authorized sale of recombinant seeds exhausts patent rights in progeny seeds that were not themselves the subject of an authorized sale. He bases this argument on a theory that subsequent generations of seeds are "embodied” in the first-generation authorized seeds.  Bowman is apparently attempting to leverage the Supreme Court's questionable use of the term "embodies" with respect to method patents in Quanta.  He also argues that production of progeny seeds does not constitute "making" the seeds because the use of genetically modified seeds inherently results in the production of progeny seeds. Bowman contends that contract law provides adequate remedies to owners of patents on self-replicating technologies.
Center for Food Safety argues that extending patent exhaustion to progeny seeds will benefit farmers by curtailing Monsanto's patent enforcement actions targeting farmers. The Center also claims that extending the patent exhaustion doctrine in this way will benefit scientific research and innovation in agriculture, and lower the cost of farming. The Center further contends the Federal Circuit's decision is contrary to Quanta, and reiterates petitioner's argument that producing progeny seed constitutes use of the patented seed, not making it, and hence falls within the scope of patent exhaustion. The amici voice is concerned that farmers whose fields have been "contaminated” by Monsanto's patented seeds could be subject to infringement lawsuits.
The American Antitrust Institute argue that the Federal Circuit's decision is contrary to Supreme Court precedent, particularly Quanta, and departs from long-standing Congressional patent policy.  They warn that the Federal Circuit's decision "portends dangerous unintended consequences" for other industries, particularly the computer software industry. They suggest that Monsanto should learn from the software industry, and engage in "effective product differentiation and efficient third-degree price discrimination" in order to counter the threat posed by the ease with which their products can be replicated. They contend that Monsanto could have avoided its need to rely on patents by not working with soybean seeds and other inbred seed lines, and confining their activities to hybrid seeds (i.e., corn) that do not produce true copies of themselves. Somewhat surprisingly, the Institute suggests that Monsanto "could have developed its ‘terminator’ gene, which would have rendered progeny seeds sterile." “Terminator” is a pejorative term for Genetic Use Restriction Technology (GURT), highly controversial technology that Monsanto pledged not to use in 1999.
The Automotive Aftermarket Industry Association et al. are concerned that affirmance of the Federal Circuit's decision weakens the patent exhaustion doctrine. This brief was filed on behalf of companies that market automotive replacement parts and refurbished inkjet cartridges.
Knowledge Ecology International essentially argues that effective patent protection is not necessary for self-replicating genetically engineered crops, because "a plethora of alternative mechanisms to patent regimes exist to reward research and development."  For example, they argue that an inventor "can still protect his investment through contractual agreements governing post-sale uses” (while at the same time acknowledging that contract law would not have helped in this case, due to a lack of privity between Bowman and Monsanto).  The plethora of alternative mechanisms includes "sui generis systems of rewards or cash innovation inducement prizes," which KEI characterizes as "viable alternatives to the patent system."  They voice concern that "even plants exhibiting the genetically modified trait found in the wild as a result of cross-pollination, would fall under the patent rights the patent holder.)
The Public Patent Foundation expresses concern that under the Federal Circuit's ruling, "contaminated farmers are infringers," and "Monsanto's customers routinely make and sell new infringing articles." In a previous post, I discussed a lawsuit that the Public Patent Foundation has filed against Monsanto on behalf of a variety of groups including associations of organic farmers.
 
 
 

54 comments:

Anonymous said...

For what it's worth, while transgenic hybrids cannot be productively replanted by farmers regardless of legal protection, they can be cannabalized and their transgenic traits sold by competeting companies at a fraction of the R&D time and cost required to create the novel trait in the first place. I don't see how overturning this protection would avoid severly chilling a technology/market that, as it is, is already only profitable for the most massive market traits.

@mattvdileo

zarash khan said...

Thanks for sharing This is a great post, I stumbled across your article while looking for some random stuff. Thanks for sharing, I’ll be sure to return regularly.

PENNY STOCK INVESTMENTS said...

Here we go again.

How apple pay works with passbook? said...

I love the blog. Great post. It is very true, people must learn how to learn before they can learn. lol i know it sounds funny but its very true.

mole repeller maker said...

This post is very simple to read and appreciate without leaving any details out. Great work! You completed certain reliable points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will agree with your blog mole repeller maker

kenya safari holidays said...

The real estate companies and the medical industry is one of the richest now. spare something more. I wish to donate too.kenya safari holidays

Robert Jennifer said...

I would love to stop by. But, I think it might have to wait until this summer. I did not know that Serlkay had ever expanded its size. vietnam tour

ladbrokes casino online said...

This is very much satisfied by the nice info is visible in this blog that to using the great services in this betting sites. Thanks a lot for using the great approach is visible in this ladbrokes casino online and utilize the nice services in this ladbrokes bingo online.

online sports gambling said...

Wonderful technology is visible in this betting sports online that to really love the great services in this sports gambling online. I am searching the great technology is visible in this blog and using the great services in this blog and sharing the great services in this online sports betting info.

fast poker said...

I am very much happy for the great info is visible in this online poker. This is very much happy for the wonderful info is visible in this bets and using the great technology in this online poker tables.

Unknown said...

This is truly fulfilled by the pleasant data is unmistakable in this poker online and utilizing the colossal administrations as a part of this best poker journal. I am truly fulfilled by the decent innovation is unmistakable in this free casino and offering the immense methodology is noticeable in this web journal.

Unknown said...

What an astonishing innovation is obvious in this play poker journal and utilizing the pleasant administrations as a part of this poker sites. I am all that much fulfilled by the pleasant administrations in this site and offering the decent data is noticeable in this online gambling.

gambling online said...

I'm greatly pleased for giving the great technological innovation is visible with this blog page. Thanks a lot for supplying the great details is visible in this weblog and utilizing the nice technological know-how on this website.

Unknown said...

This is really approach is visible in this blog that to sharing the amazing info is visible in this information technology blog. I am really like it very much for using the great info is visible in this blog and the wonderful info is using the nice services in this blog. This is really admired for the great services in this blog that to using the nice approach I visible in this tablet reviews blog.

PATIOS Sydney said...

Blakeslee and Son really helped us out when we had a plumbing issue. We are in Grand Rapids and would highly recommend their services!PATIOS Sydney

limo Seattle  said...

well she is such a great performer and i love her performance so much and she is doing a superb job and thanks you share some of about her in this website.limo Seattle

lawyers West Palm Beach said...

I stumbled upon your own site perfect on your own would like. Their particular details attributes wonderful along with things. We now have examine most of them along with bought a large bin off from their site. Regards on the details post. Certainly cya! Fantastic. Regards on the find out.lawyers West Palm Beach

robinsonfps.com said...

Your blog specializing in going above the certain lacking a apprehension contemptuous along on their possess released constrains.robinsonfps.com

auto accident attorney plantation said...

Just like in brick and mortar stores you can also find discount shopping online as like anything else you can find anything you want with only a few clicks of the mouse. While the brick-and-mortar is a plus for getting outdoors it can also be inconvenient and stressful.auto accident attorney plantation

silicone mug cover said...

This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article.silicone mug cover

Adoption Teacup Kittens on Sale said...

I am very happy to read this. This blog was really an awesome site, Continue blogging new and entertaining posts. Adoption Teacup Kittens on Sale

pheasant feathers bulk said...

Excellent work! It’s a pleasure to read your blog. Looking forward to read more blogs from this platform.pheasant feathers bulk

1960s Fashion said...

the great info is visible in this blog and the different ideas for visiting the nice technology. Thanks a lot for visiting the nice technology and using the great info is visible in this blog. This is really like it.1960s Fashion

Anonymous said...

Very good post.
Thank you for providing me with useful information, we can organize a tour of Asean: Vietnam, Combodia, Myanmar, Thailand...you are interested please afford survey.
Tourist agency | Travel companies
Tourist agency | Vietnam cuisine
Thailand culture travel | Thailand Cuisine
Thailand cultural tour | Foods and drinks in Thailand
Travel services agency | Travel agencies

company career sites said...

I want to express my admiration of your writing skill and ability to make readers read from the beginning to the end. I would like to read newer posts and to share my thoughts with you.company career sites

postings site said...

Must confess that you present powerful steps on this blog and therefore has strongly encouraged contribution on this subjectpostings site

Brazil carnival 2017 said...

This informative article will help those who read and Thanks for sharing this great info with everyone.Brazil carnival 2017

Resin Drives Diy Kit said...

The results you could have well prepared could be great. Due to the fact photos finest which often type of products ever since extended a similar later currently the determine is usually carried out as well as the virtually all caused by particular person. Your blog the item really is not at all just educative a similar swift process in addition. Yet again appreciation.Resin Drives Diy Kit

compare prepaid cards said...

Congratulations on a career well achieved. This arrange is synchronous s informative impolite festivity to pity. I appreciated what you ok extremely here.compare prepaid cards

advantages of refinancing your mortgage said...

I am still learning from you, but I am trying to achieve my goals. I certainly enjoy reading all that is posted on your blog. Keeps the information coming. I loved it.advantages of refinancing your mortgage

law veritas said...

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!law veritas

tactical shooting schools said...

A very legitimate criticism of the experiment. I am reasonable confident that the variation was not due to experimental error but this hasn't been demonstrated at all.tactical shooting schools

dealership cleaning company said...

I would love to stop by. But, I think it might have to wait until this summer. I did not know that Serlkay had ever expanded its size. I must say that a succesful family owned business in this day and age is a very refreshing sight! As well as this is a very refreshing site!dealership cleaning company

Robert Jennifer said...

he position of the syllabic feature can describe why titles like Bella or Arianna seem “longer” or more “frilly” than Age or Penelope, despite being the same duration when verbal.Vintage clothing online

Robert Jennifer said...

Thanks for the tips you write about through this blog. In addition, numerous young women which become pregnant don’t even try and get health care insurance because they are concerned they would not qualify.Locksmith Swords

Robert Jennifer said...

This post is very simple to read and appreciate without leaving any details out. Great work! You completed certain reliable points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will agree with your blog.real estate news

Legal Herbal Online said...

Thank you, I've been seeking for info about this subject matter for ages and yours is the best I have discovered so far.B & b viareggio and surroundings

Sophie Grace said...

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work net worth

Legal Herbal Online said...

nice location voiture agadir pas cher

Robert Jennifer said...

Love this post! Cooking eggs always seems easy but it’s not as easy as it sounds. Maybe you could share your tips on perfect scrambled eggs.custom-driveway-gates.com

Robert Jennifer said...

I love the blog. Great post. It is very true, people must learn how to learn before they can learn. lol i know it sounds funny but its very true.Wholesale fashion

Robert Jennifer said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Coinpublish said...

Coinpublish provides latest Blockchain and Cryptocurrency news
Coinpublish is an independent publication working for a decentralized economy and delivering you with the latest updates on ICO, Bitcoin, Ethereum and Altcoin news.
cryptocurrency news , ICO news , Latest Blockchain news , Bitcoin news , Ethereum news , Altcoin news
We are the independent publication delivering news around cryptocurrency news, ICO news & Latest Blockchain news. Our platform focuses on providing news around blockchain, cryptocurrencies, distributed systems and decentralized global economy. We regularly keeps its readers updated on Bitcoin news, Ethereum news & Altcoin news. For all crypto enthusiasts, Coinpublish is the place to be.

We make great efforts in contributing to gather unbiased and reliable information for our dedicated and influential readers across the globe. All updated information regarding price change, developments and technological advancements in cryptoverse are available on Coinpublish. Our platform allows marketers to promote latest news in the form of Press releases & Advertisements.

Our mission is to enlighten the world about the pros and cons of cryptocurrency and blockchain. When we decided to start Coinpublish, we were in a race with strong competitors. We had to be better and different. For this, we chose to roll the dice to come up with unique ideas in order to make the platform user-friendly and informative.

To know more about coinpublish visit the given link - www.coinpublish.com/

Connect to Coinpublish through given links:
Facebook - https://www.facebook.com/coinpublishdaily/
Twitter -twitter.com/Coin_Publish
Linkedin - in.linkedin.com/company/coinpublish

Shen Tong said...

Shen Tong is an Angel Investor and has invested in plenty of start-ups related to the food industry. Shen Tong is an entrepreneur and is extensively involved in the media industry and software industry. Shen Tong is the founder and president of VFinity and is also in the board of directors of Food Tank. VFinity essentially is responsible for making web applications for multimedia and multilingual search, software tools, media production, archiving, and media distribution.Shen Tong moved to the city of New York and founded business accelerators: FoodFutureCo in the year 2015 and Food-X in the year 2014.
Shen Tong is widely acknowledged because of the speech he made on the promotion of context media and suppression of the National Association of Broadcasters in Las Vegas. Apart from being a sequential entrepreneur, Shen Tong is a writer/poet, social activist, a film buff and a foodie. Shen Tong holds an honorary Ph.D. degree from St Ambrose University. It was in the year 2000 when Shen Tong moved to the city of New York and founded business accelerators: FoodFutureCo in the year 2015 and Food-X in the year 2014.Shen Tong co-chaired a committee designed to form a dialogue concerning the Chinese pro-democracy movement.Shen Tong organised the democracy movement in 1989 that occupied Tiananmen Square while he was at Beijing University.

Robert Jennifer said...

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.
Costa Calida

Location voiture Marrakech aéroport said...

This was great topic. Thanks!
Location voiture Marrakech aéroport
تـأجير السيارات مراكش المطار
Agence de sécurité Agadir
Location voiture Casablanca aéroport
Fast track Rabat
Fast track Fes
Fast track Agadir
Fast track Maroc

Johnson Hack said...

Livewebtutors aims at providing the students with a one stop solution for all the academic related issues. The company has Livewebtutors is an online Assignment Help and assignment writing service offering expert assignment help. Hire Australian assignment writing experts.minneapolis web developer

Johnson Hack said...



This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.minneapolis web developer

Johnson Hack said...

Thank you for benefiting from time to focus on this kind of, I feel firmly about it and also really like comprehending far more with this particular subject matter. In case doable, when you get know-how, is it possible to thoughts modernizing your site together with far more details? It’s extremely useful to me.minneapolis wordpress expert

Johnson Hack said...

One of the best ways to assess a lawyer’s legal ability is by interviewing them. Most attorneys will provide an initial consultation at no charge.minneapolis wordpress expert

Robert Jennifer said...


I laughed out loud, shed some tears … Scrambled Eggs is a theatrical feast for women of all ages and the men who love them!" and CBS’ Magee Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real.
Workout clothing

Mehvish said...

Benefit utilizing your facts, the optimal recognized by themselves excellent. Benefit yet again designed relevant to delivering people personal unique personal computer system facts.
Social Media Management

Anonymous said...


Dental Services in New Jersey since 1998-Hamilton Dental Care. Offers a variety of dental services in Hamilton to meet all of your dental needs. Let’s say if you are searching for the cosmetic dentistry near me or cosmetic dentistry hamilton NJ then you might come across with the Hamilton Dental Care because it is the best dental health services provider in the NJ. It gives you a smile that you can be proud to show off.

Dental Services - https://www.hamiltondentalcarenj.com
Facebook Profile - https://www.facebook.com/Hamilton-Dental-Care-153063602028984/
Yelp Profile - https://www.yelp.com/biz/hamilton-dental-care-hamilton-township

naaptol-winner-list-2020 said...

winner list naaptol here came up with an Offer where you can win special Naaptol Prize list by just playing a game & win prizes Call @8404917617
winner list naaptol
winner name naaptol
naaptol prize department
prize department naaptol
lucky draw naaptol
Naaptol Prize list